thinkhard.SI

Prompt repository Study & school

Check that each paragraph backs its claim with evidence and explanation

You have a draft and want to see which body paragraphs back their point with evidence and explain it, and which ones skip a step.

Registry no.
STU-029
Collection
Study & school
Laid out for
Any chat model
Score
10 out of 10
Blanks to fill
3

Study & schoolAny chat

The prompt

Score 10 of 10, Excellent

Use it when You have a draft and want to see which body paragraphs back their point with evidence and explain it, and which ones skip a step.

  • {{thesis}}
  • {{paragraphs}}
  • {{structure_name}}
Full prompt and why it works
Prompt
Check the structure of each body paragraph in my draft, so that I can see which ones hold up and which skip a step. I will do the revising, so diagnose; do not rewrite.

My thesis: {{thesis}}

The body paragraphs, numbered:
"""
{{paragraphs}}
"""

The name my instructor uses for this structure, if any: {{structure_name}}

In each paragraph, look for four parts:
- Claim: a sentence that states the paragraph's point and connects it to the thesis.
- Evidence: a quote, a statistic, an example or a detail from the text, introduced and cited.
- Explanation: my own sentences on how the evidence proves the claim. This is the part students most often skip or replace with more summary.
- Link: a closing move that ties the point back to the thesis or leads into the next paragraph.

Produce a table with one row per paragraph and the columns Paragraph, Claim, Evidence, Explanation, Link, Biggest fix. In the four part columns, write Present, Weak, Misplaced or Missing, followed by a few quoted words showing where it is. In Biggest fix, say in one sentence what is missing or out of place, for example "Evidence is a long quote with no explanation after it; add two sentences of your own on what it shows." That example shows the form only.

After the table, add at most four lines on patterns across the paragraphs, such as every paragraph ending on a quote.

A good check is one I can act on paragraph by paragraph in ten minutes. Judge structure only, not the strength of my argument or my grammar. Do not suggest new evidence or write replacement sentences, even as examples built from my own paragraph.

If a paragraph is doing a different job, such as background or a counterargument, say so instead of forcing it into the four parts. If you cannot tell which sentence is the claim, mark it Weak and say why.

Variables

{{thesis}}
Your thesis statement, so each claim can be checked against it.
{{paragraphs}}
Your body paragraphs, numbered, copied from your draft.
{{structure_name}}
What your class calls it, for example "PEEL" or "CER". Write "none" if there is no name.

Why it works

  • Format. One table row per paragraph, with a verdict for each part and a single biggest fix, makes it clear where to start revising.
  • What good looks like. The explanation step is singled out because it is the one students most often skip, and the check is built to be acted on in ten minutes.
  • What to avoid. It judges structure only and writes no replacement sentences, so the student does the revising.

How to use it

  1. Press Fill in blanks and type your details into each blank. What you type stays in this browser.
  2. Copy the filled prompt into the AI tool you already use, such as ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini, or open it in the Grader or the Prompt Tester here.
  3. Before you rely on it, try it on three or four real examples. The Prompt Tester runs them all at once and shows which ones go wrong.
  4. When the answer comes back, check it before you use it. The Fact Check List lists every figure, quote and source in the answer worth checking, riskiest first.
Use it from code

Get this prompt as JSON from the free REST API, with your own text in the blanks, or let an AI assistant fetch it through the MCP server. No key.

curl -s https://thinkhard.si/api/v1/prompts/paragraph-claim-evidence-check

With the MCP server added to Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor or VS Code, call get_prompt with {"prompt": "paragraph-claim-evidence-check"}, or just ask for it by name.