thinkhard.SI

Prompt repository Study & school

Get feedback on my thesis statement before I start drafting

You have a draft thesis and want to know whether it makes a clear, arguable claim your evidence can support before you write the essay.

Registry no.
STU-027
Collection
Study & school
Laid out for
Any chat model
Score
10 out of 10
Blanks to fill
5

Study & schoolAny chat

The prompt

Score 10 of 10, Excellent

Use it when You have a draft thesis and want to know whether it makes a clear, arguable claim your evidence can support before you write the essay.

  • {{course}}
  • {{assignment_prompt}}
  • {{thesis}}
  • {{evidence_summary}}
  • {{length}}
Full prompt and why it works
Prompt
Give me feedback on my thesis statement for {{course}}, so that I can fix it before I build the whole essay on it. I want to do the rewriting myself, so diagnose the problems and ask me questions; do not hand me a finished thesis.

The assignment prompt, as my instructor wrote it:
"""
{{assignment_prompt}}
"""

My draft thesis:
"""
{{thesis}}
"""

What I plan to use as evidence, briefly: {{evidence_summary}}
Essay length: {{length}}

Judge the thesis against these tests, in this order, one short paragraph each, with a verdict of Strong, Close, Needs work or Missing:
1. It answers the assignment prompt, not a nearby question.
2. It is arguable: a reasonable reader could disagree, so it is not a plain fact or a summary of the topic.
3. It is specific enough for the length: it narrows the topic to a particular case, group, place or period.
4. My planned evidence could support every part of it.
5. It hints at the reasoning, with words such as "because", "although", "by" or "despite", so a reader can predict the shape of the essay.

Then give me:
- The single biggest problem, in one sentence.
- Three to five questions that would help me sharpen it, for example "Which of your two reasons matters more, and why?" That example shows the kind of question only.
- Two different directions the thesis could take, each described in a phrase, not written as a thesis sentence.

Keep the whole answer under 350 words. Be direct: a thesis that only restates the topic should be told so plainly, because vague praise wastes my time. Do not rewrite the thesis, and do not judge whether my position is right, only whether it is well made.

If the assignment prompt is missing or could be read two ways, say how you read it and what would change under the other reading.

Variables

{{course}}
The course, for example "10th grade English" or "Introduction to Sociology".
{{assignment_prompt}}
The essay prompt, copied from the assignment sheet.
{{thesis}}
Your draft thesis statement, exactly as you wrote it.
{{evidence_summary}}
A line or two on the sources or examples you plan to use.
{{length}}
The essay length, for example "5 pages" or "1,000 words".

Why it works

  • What good looks like. Five named tests with a verdict each turn "is my thesis good?" into specific problems a student can fix one at a time.
  • What to avoid. The AI diagnoses and asks questions but never writes the thesis, and it judges how the claim is made, not whether the student's view is right.
  • If unsure. A prompt that can be read two ways is named, with what would change under the other reading, so the student does not build on a misreading.

How to use it

  1. Press Fill in blanks and type your details into each blank. What you type stays in this browser.
  2. Copy the filled prompt into the AI tool you already use, such as ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini, or open it in the Grader or the Prompt Tester here.
  3. Before you rely on it, try it on three or four real examples. The Prompt Tester runs them all at once and shows which ones go wrong.
  4. When the answer comes back, check it before you use it. The Fact Check List lists every figure, quote and source in the answer worth checking, riskiest first.
Use it from code

Get this prompt as JSON from the free REST API, with your own text in the blanks, or let an AI assistant fetch it through the MCP server. No key.

curl -s https://thinkhard.si/api/v1/prompts/thesis-statement-feedback

With the MCP server added to Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor or VS Code, call get_prompt with {"prompt": "thesis-statement-feedback"}, or just ask for it by name.