The prompt
Score 10 of 10, Excellent
Use it when You are writing an argumentative essay and want the best objections to your thesis, so you can answer them yourself in the essay.
- {{course}}
- {{thesis}}
- {{reasons}}
- {{audience}}
Full prompt and why it works
Prompt
Find the strongest counterarguments to the thesis of my essay for {{course}}, so that I can decide which to address and write the response myself. An essay that answers the best objection is more convincing than one that knocks down a weak one. My thesis: """ {{thesis}} """ My main reasons and evidence, briefly: """ {{reasons}} """ Who the essay is written for: {{audience}} Give me these parts, in this order: 1. Four counterarguments, ranked from the most to the least damaging. For each: - The objection, stated the way a thoughtful person who disagrees would put it, in two sentences or fewer. - Which of my reasons it attacks. - The kind of evidence that would support it, described in general terms, for me to look for in my own sources. - My options: concede part of it, refute it, narrow my thesis to avoid it, or acknowledge it briefly. Say which seems most promising and why, in one line. 2. The objection a grader would most expect to see addressed, if it differs from the top of the ranking. 3. Where in my essay a counterargument paragraph would fit best, given my reasons. Keep it under 450 words. For example, an objection in the right form: "Your evidence comes from one city with unusual funding, so a reader may doubt it applies elsewhere. This attacks your second reason." That shows the form only. Do not write the counterargument paragraph or my rebuttal. Do not cite studies, authors, statistics or quotes from memory; describe the kind of source instead, so I can find a real one. Leave out straw men that no informed reader would hold. If my thesis is vague enough to be read two ways, say so and aim the objections at the reading I most likely mean.
Variables
- {{course}}
- The course, for example "12th grade government" or "Ethics 101".
- {{thesis}}
- Your thesis statement.
- {{reasons}}
- Your main reasons and the evidence for each, in note form.
- {{audience}}
- Who the essay is for, for example "my instructor" or "readers of the school paper".
Why it works
- What to make. It asks for ranked objections with the reason each attacks and the options for answering it, so the student chooses the response and writes it.
- What to avoid. No studies or figures from memory and no straw men: the student gets the kind of evidence to look for, not citations that may not exist.
- If unsure. A thesis that can be read two ways is named as such before the objections are aimed at it.