thinkhard.SI

Prompt repository Study & school

Judge whether a source is credible enough to cite in my paper

You found a source for a paper and want to know if it is trustworthy enough to cite, and what to check before you rely on it.

Registry no.
STU-031
Collection
Study & school
Laid out for
Any chat model
Score
10 out of 10
Blanks to fill
5

Study & schoolAny chat

The prompt

Score 10 of 10, Excellent

Use it when You found a source for a paper and want to know if it is trustworthy enough to cite, and what to check before you rely on it.

  • {{course}}
  • {{source_rules}}
  • {{source_details}}
  • {{excerpt}}
  • {{planned_use}}
Full prompt and why it works
Prompt
Help me judge whether the source below is credible enough to cite in my paper for {{course}}, so that I do not build an argument on something my instructor will reject.

My instructor's rules for sources: {{source_rules}}

What I know about the source (title, author, publisher or website, date, type, and the claim I want to use it for):
"""
{{source_details}}
"""

An excerpt of the part I want to cite, if I have it:
"""
{{excerpt}}
"""

How I plan to use it in the paper: {{planned_use}}

Work through these questions, in this order, a few sentences each:
1. Who is behind it: the author's expertise on this topic, and who published or paid for it.
2. What kind of source it is: peer-reviewed research, a news report, an opinion piece, a government or organization report, a personal page or something else, and what that type is good evidence for.
3. Evidence: does the excerpt show where its claims come from (data, methods, citations or named sources), or does it just assert them?
4. Date and fit: is it current enough for this topic, and does it support the specific claim I want, or only something nearby?
5. Checks I should do myself: what to search to see what other sources say about this author or publisher, and whether to trace a statistic back to where it first appeared.

Then give a verdict: Cite it, Cite with care, Use only as background, or Find a better source. Add one sentence on what a stronger source for the same claim would look like. For example, a verdict in the right form: "Cite with care: it is an advocacy group's report, so present its figure as that group's estimate and pair it with an independent source." That shows the form only.

Keep it under 400 words. Base your judgment only on the details I gave. You may not have reliable information about this author or outlet, so do not state facts about them from memory. Where a judgment depends on a detail I did not give, mark it [CHECK: what to look up] instead of assuming.

A good answer teaches me the checks as well as giving a verdict, so I can run them on my next source myself.

Variables

{{course}}
The course, for example "AP Psychology" or "Environmental Science 201".
{{source_rules}}
What your instructor allows, for example "at least two peer-reviewed sources, no Wikipedia". Write "none given" if there are no rules.
{{source_details}}
Title, author, publisher or site, date, type of source, and the claim you want to cite it for.
{{excerpt}}
The passage you want to use, copied from the source. Write "none" if you do not have it.
{{planned_use}}
How you will use it, for example "as the main evidence for my second point" or "for background only".

Why it works

  • If unsure. The AI judges only from the details given and marks anything it would need to look up with [CHECK], rather than vouching for an author or outlet from memory.
  • Format. Five questions in a fixed order end in one of four verdicts, so the student gets a decision as well as the reasoning behind it.
  • Who it's for. The checks are explained so the student can run them alone on the next source, which is the skill the assignment is building.

How to use it

  1. Press Fill in blanks and type your details into each blank. What you type stays in this browser.
  2. Copy the filled prompt into the AI tool you already use, such as ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini, or open it in the Grader or the Prompt Tester here.
  3. Before you rely on it, try it on three or four real examples. The Prompt Tester runs them all at once and shows which ones go wrong.
  4. When the answer comes back, check it before you use it. The Fact Check List lists every figure, quote and source in the answer worth checking, riskiest first.
Use it from code

Get this prompt as JSON from the free REST API, with your own text in the blanks, or let an AI assistant fetch it through the MCP server. No key.

curl -s https://thinkhard.si/api/v1/prompts/source-credibility-check

With the MCP server added to Claude, ChatGPT, Cursor or VS Code, call get_prompt with {"prompt": "source-credibility-check"}, or just ask for it by name.