The prompt
Score 10 of 10, Excellent
Use it when You have a passage that feels flat and want to know where it tells the reader what to feel, and how you could show it instead.
- {{passage}}
- {{context}}
Full prompt and why it works
Prompt
Give me show-don't-tell feedback on my passage, so that I can see where I am telling the reader what to think or feel and decide for myself where to dramatize instead. I will do the rewriting. You point and explain, with at most one short illustration per spot. The passage: """ {{passage}} """ Context: where this passage sits in the story, who is in it, the point of view, and what the reader should feel by the end of it: """ {{context}} """ Look for: - Named emotions, for example "she was furious" or "he felt lonely", where action, gesture, dialogue or a physical sensation could carry it. - Summary of a moment that matters, where the reader would gain from being in the scene. - Character traits stated by the narrator ("she was generous") instead of shown in a choice. - Explanations right after something was shown, which tell the reader what they just saw. Telling is not always wrong. Summary is the right tool for transitions, time jumps, routine and minor events, so leave those alone and say so when you pass one. Format: a numbered list of up to eight spots, most important first. For each one: 1. The sentence, quoted exactly. 2. What kind of telling it is, from the list above. 3. Why it matters here, in one sentence: what the reader loses. 4. One possible way to show it, in under 40 words, labeled "Illustration only" so I write my own version. End with two sentences on what the passage already does well, quoting it, so I keep doing it. A good note names a specific loss, such as the reader not getting to work out the anger for themselves, rather than citing a rule. In your illustrations, match my tense and point of view. Do not rewrite the passage as a whole, and do not flag every abstract word; choose the spots where showing would change the reader's experience most. Avoid suggestions that add melodrama, like clenched fists and racing hearts in every scene. If the context is missing and you cannot tell what the reader should feel, ask me before giving feedback rather than guessing.
Variables
- {{passage}}
- The passage you want feedback on, up to a few pages.
- {{context}}
- Where it falls in the story, who is in it, the point of view and what the reader should feel by the end.
Why it works
- What good looks like. Each note names what the reader loses at that spot, rather than citing the rule, so you can weigh it.
- What to avoid. Summary that does its job, such as a transition, is left alone, and illustrations are labeled so the rewrite stays yours.
- Length. Up to eight spots, most important first, keeps the feedback on the changes that matter.