The prompt
Score 10 of 10, Excellent
Use it when You have a chapter draft and want big-picture feedback on its story and pacing before you spend time on line edits.
- {{chapter}}
- {{book_context}}
- {{genre_and_readers}}
- {{my_concerns}}
Full prompt and why it works
Prompt
Give me a developmental critique of my manuscript chapter, the kind an editor gives before any line editing, so that I know what to fix at the level of story before I polish sentences. Be honest and specific. I want the real problems, ranked, with your reasoning, and I will decide what to change. The chapter: """ {{chapter}} """ Where it sits: the book's premise, who the point-of-view character is, what happened before this chapter and what this chapter has to do for the book: """ {{book_context}} """ Genre and readers: {{genre_and_readers}} What I am worried about in this chapter: {{my_concerns}} Read it as a whole first, then answer under these headings: 1. What this chapter does: two or three sentences on what happens and what changes, as you read it. If that differs from what I said the chapter has to do, say so here. 2. What is working: up to four strengths, each with a short quote, so I keep them. 3. The biggest problems, ranked, up to five. For each: what the problem is, where it shows (quote or describe the passage), why it costs the reader, and one or two ways to approach it. Look at stakes, the main character's goal in the chapter, pacing, point-of-view control, scene openings and endings, cause and effect, and whether the chapter ends with a reason to turn the page. 4. Questions for me: things you could not judge without knowing the rest of the book. Keep it under 900 words. A good critique is specific enough that I could find each problem in the text, and it treats the chapter on its own terms and genre, not as the book you would write. Do not line edit or rewrite passages; if prose problems get in the way of the story, mention the pattern once. Do not soften real problems into compliments, and do not invent problems to fill the list. Avoid generic advice such as "raise the stakes" without saying how in this chapter. If my context is too thin to judge whether something is a problem (for example, a thread that may pay off later), put it under Questions rather than calling it a flaw.
Variables
- {{chapter}}
- The full chapter.
- {{book_context}}
- The premise, the point-of-view character, what came before and what this chapter must do.
- {{genre_and_readers}}
- For example "upmarket women's fiction" or "middle grade fantasy, ages 8 to 12".
- {{my_concerns}}
- What you are worried about, for example "the middle drags". Write "none" if nothing specific.
Why it works
- Length. Up to five ranked problems in under 900 words keeps the critique at the level of story, and line edits are left out on purpose.
- What good looks like. Each problem must be specific enough to find in the text, judged on the chapter's own terms and genre.
- If unsure. Anything that might pay off later in the book becomes a question for you instead of a flaw.