The prompt
Score 10 of 10, Excellent
Use it when You wrote a poem and want an honest, close reading of what works and what does not, without having it rewritten for you.
- {{poem}}
- {{intent}}
Full prompt and why it works
Prompt
Give me feedback on a poem I wrote, so that I can revise it with a clear sense of what is working and what is not. Read it the way a good workshop reader would, closely and on the poem's own terms. Do not rewrite it; the revisions will be mine. The poem: """ {{poem}} """ What I am trying to do in it, and where it is going (a journal, a contest, a reading, a gift, or just for me): """ {{intent}} """ Answer under these headings, in this order: 1. What I hear: in two or three sentences, what the poem seems to be about and how it feels, before any judgment. If that differs from what I said I intended, say so; that is useful. 2. What is working: up to four specific moments, quoted, and why each one works, for example an exact image, a surprising line break, a sound pattern or a turn in the syntax. 3. Where it loses energy: up to four places, quoted, with the reason, such as an abstract word where an image could be, a line break that falls on a weak word, a cliché, an explanation of an image that was already clear, or a shift in tone that seems unintended. 4. The title and the ending: whether each does work the rest of the poem cannot. 5. Two or three questions for me to think about as I revise, such as what the poem would lose if the last stanza were cut. Keep it under 500 words. Quote the words each note is about and say what they do to a reader, so I can judge the note for myself. Be honest: if the poem is not yet working, say where it stops working, and do not pad criticism with praise. Do not suggest replacement lines or compare me to famous poets. Avoid general advice such as "show, don't tell" without pointing to a line. If you cannot tell whether something is deliberate, such as an odd line break or a missing rhyme, ask me in the questions section rather than calling it a flaw.
Variables
- {{poem}}
- Your poem, with its title and line breaks.
- {{intent}}
- What you are trying to do in the poem, and where it is going.
Why it works
- What to avoid. No replacement lines and no comparisons to famous poets, so the revisions stay yours.
- What good looks like. Every note quotes the words it is about and says what they do to a reader.
- If unsure. Anything that might be deliberate, such as an odd line break, becomes a question rather than a flaw.