The prompt
Score 10 of 10, Excellent
Use it when You got comments on a draft from a teacher or a peer and want to understand them and turn them into a revision plan you will carry out yourself.
- {{course}}
- {{feedback}}
- {{draft}}
- {{time}}
- {{reaction}}
Full prompt and why it works
Prompt
Help me make sense of the feedback I got on my draft and turn it into a plan for my next draft in {{course}}, so that I fix what matters most and learn from it for the next assignment. I will do all the revising myself, so explain and plan; do not rewrite any part of my draft. The feedback, exactly as given (comments, rubric marks, grades, margin notes with the text they refer to): """ {{feedback}} """ My draft, or the parts the comments refer to: """ {{draft}} """ The next deadline and how much time I have: {{time}} My honest first reaction to the feedback: {{reaction}} Produce: 1. What the feedback is saying: group the comments into themes, such as argument, evidence, organization or citations, and restate each theme in plain words. Where a comment is short or cryptic, such as "vague" or "so what?", explain what a grader usually means by it and which sentence of mine it points to. 2. Priorities: a table with the columns Theme, Comments it covers, Effect on the grade (High or Low), Effort, Do first. Big-picture issues come before sentence-level fixes, because polishing sentences in a paragraph that will be cut wastes time. 3. The plan: numbered steps that fit my time, each a concrete action I will take, for example "Reread paragraphs 2 and 4 and write in the margin how each quote supports the thesis." That shows the form only. 4. One habit to carry into my next assignment, drawn from a pattern across the comments. 5. A reply to my reaction in two sentences or fewer, honest rather than flattering. Keep it under 450 words. Do not argue with my instructor's judgments or soften them, and do not add new criticism of your own beyond the feedback, except to flag one issue I should ask about. If a comment is ambiguous or seems to conflict with another, list it under "Ask your instructor" with the question I could ask.
Variables
- {{course}}
- The course, for example "AP Language" or "History 150".
- {{feedback}}
- Every comment you got, with the sentence or paragraph each refers to.
- {{draft}}
- Your draft, or the paragraphs the comments are about.
- {{time}}
- When the next draft is due and how many hours you can give it.
- {{reaction}}
- How you feel about the feedback, for example "I don't understand what 'go deeper' means".
Why it works
- What to make. It sorts the feedback into themes and priorities before any revising, so the student fixes big problems before small ones.
- What to avoid. The instructor's judgments are not argued with or softened, and no part of the draft is rewritten.
- If unsure. Ambiguous or conflicting comments go under "Ask your instructor" with a ready question, instead of being guessed at.